welcome

Mamas of lost babies and potential of all kinds: come here to share the technicolour, the vividness, the despair, the heart-broken-open, the compassion we learn for others, having been through this mess — and see it reflected back at you, acknowledged, understood.

subscribe
search

Powered by Squarespace

Add to Technorati Favorites
« In the absence of miracles | Main | the 'are you there, god? it's me, medusa' blogolympics »
Monday
29Sep

the charnel ground

 

Glow's premiere feature for the Are You There, God? It's Me, Medusa blogolympics comes from Buddhist mama and author Katie Willis Morton.

Katie's son Liam was born with profound brain damage. When he died six-and-a-half weeks later, she embarked on a wider search for solace.

Katie is the author of The Blue Poppy and the Mustard Seed: A Mother's Story of Loss and Hope, due out this month from Wisdom Publications and excerpted, in variation, here with permission. She is also a contributor to the anthology Mourning Sickness from Omniarts.

She continues to try to play through the days of chaos, working toward wisdom, graced with the good karma of having Liam's brother and sister at her sides.

We're deeply honoured to have Katie among us to share her Buddhist perspective—that all our babies are cherished miracles and teachers.



"Chaos is part of our home ground. Instead of looking for something higher or purer, work with it just as it is the chaos in here and the chaos out there is basic energy, the play of wisdom . . . the basis of freedom and the basis of confusion . . . This charnel ground called life is the manifestation of wisdom.”
                                                                                  Pema Chödrön

The Ganges, and the burning ghats on it, is one of the most sacred places on earth for Hindus. Many old people give up all their possessions and go to live the last days of their lives on the banks of the Ganges bathing in her waters and praying. Corpses bound in cloth and draped in marigolds and carnations are carried daily on the shoulders of their families to the burning pyres on the ghats. Their bodies are consumed in the flames stoked with incense and prayer. The ashes are gathered and then scattered in the flowing waters where they mingle with the ashes of millions. We had no ashes to add to the river only tears and wishes.

I was a pyre—a combustible heap, consumed by chaos, and confused.

We planned to go to India to see some of the Buddha’s holy places like Lumbini, where he was born; and Bodhgaya, where he found enlightenment under an acacia tree; and Sarnath, where he gave his first teaching, and turned the Wheel of Dharma for the first time.

+++++

The lowest caste in India is said to be 'untouchable'. Orphans too are said to be untouchable, because of their great misfortune that caused them to lose their parents. I felt untouchable too.

Kids who lose parents have a name. Husbands and wives who lose their spouses have a name. What do you call parents who lose their babies? It’s an unnamed, and mostly unvoiced, situation of despair. We might call ourselves the Blue Poppy parents, the ones who have seen our children flower, for no matter how small amount of time, and die. We are in a despair that often feels ineffable, which closes us into an unseen, unaddressed, sometimes uncomforted, community. The name widow or orphan at least recognizes the beloved person who lived.

I felt an unspeakable conflict when someone asked me after Liam died if I had children. I had to choose between saying no, which seemed to betray Liam’s life, or say yes, but he died—leaving me stuck in an awkward situation because most people don’t know what to say or how to respond to an answer like that. Sometimes people say what a horrible experience that must have been with, of course, every intention of trying to sympathize. And again, if I said yes, I betray the great love and beauty and delight of him that came hand-in-hand with the horror of his diagnosis and passing. If I say no, not horrible I was afraid I’d seem indifferent, or crazy, or cold-hearted.

Wouldn’t it be nice if the morticians gave out blue poppy pins for us to wear instead of empty, ceramic hearts—a small symbol that says what needs to be said in a way that lets us all be at ease? And better, how wonderful if we knew to say something like That must have been a powerful/moving/intense experience for you. All of those descriptions would be more true than horrible.

All people no matter how small, all lives for no matter how short or long they bloom, are powerful, full of power. Blue poppies take root in mountainous scree; there is a place for happiness in the hard conversations of loss.

Now that the rooftop of the world has been explored and exported, some initiates inclined to cultivate rare plants have made blue poppies more prevalent. It’s been rare for us parents to speak of our loss, which was thought also to be rare. Now, with care, the memory of these delicate and powerful lives, our Blue Poppy Babies, can be brought into the light, and we can see we’re not alone. We can talk about them, openly, who they were and what they meant to us. To be able to, to feel allowed to, talk about our Blue Poppy children joyfully is even more rare then talking about losing them. Our kind of loss is more common then most people know. And more complex.

There is a bright center in all that darkness of my loss that speaks to me still. Liam’s existence makes me consider this moment now, consider the blessing of time, and consider the power of wisdom and skillful means.

It still amazes me that such a small person in only forty-eight days could teach me so much and hold me in an awe that inspired me to love, without too much attachment and too much aversion, the world around me.

Liam taught me just by being there. By existing. And despite his limitations and everything against him. On the phone one day my grandma told me she was praying for a miracle. He already is a miracle I told her quietly not knowing how to explain what I meant any more than that. We are all miracles, aren’t we? That we are here at all, maybe that should tell us something. Maybe, we are all small miracles, chaos of matter, capable of birthing light even with our limitations. My heart broke because of that powerful experience of Liam’s short life, but it broke it open too.

It’s not just that I loved my son Liam; when Liam was here, in concert with the crushing dread, I simply loved, unstrained and easily, without reservation, without discernment, without judgment. I was open to almost everyone that I encountered. It was a sacred experience to live in love and to gratefully accept the world with all its awful, unspeakable blessings.

What was solely horrifying was what came after the time with Liam when he revealed to me how to live within a spacious mind. Having to go on living, which is no small matter, and move on, through the chaos in here and out there. And knowing what a struggle it will be since I’m intensely aware that I’m not able in everyday to evoke this understanding he drew out of me and not give in to my horrible nature that comes hand in hand with my loving one.

+++++

We had no services when Liam passed. We waked him the only way we could at the time, instinctively, setting an altar in our front room where anyone would see it upon entering our home, keeping his presence with us the only way possible—symbolically, elliptically, and then, to go on living anyway.

 


PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (24)

This was so beautiful, Katie, and mystical... looking at that photo I feel as though I can almost smell spices in the air.

I have one of Pema Chödrön's books on my nightstand and have only breezed through it too quickly - this makes me want to go back during a more quiet moment.

Your words are so evocative... the burning pyre, the mountainous scree.

So many people have said to me of Ben, "Thank goodness he was a fighter!" or "There's your miracle baby..." and my throat always gets fat and swollen with that. The implication there is that Liam was not a fighter, that he was not a miracle. By the measure they mean - in terms of what he went through - it was technically Liam who was the miracle, who faced so much and came so far despite his challenges. Compared to him, all Ben needed to do was feed and grow. They were both miracles, though - it's just that Liam did not survive.

And to call someone who survives a 'fighter' is to say that those who do not survive gave up, or couldn't bear staying with us... I'll offer that up as one of those sad statements alongside your thoughts on 'horrible'.

Thank you so much for doing this, for sharing your Liam's teachings with us. You've made me feel more peaceful today.
September 29, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterkate
Katie, i was really moved by this, and while my time with my son was more condensed than yours, your recollection of the openness and love you experienced because of him and then "Having to go on living, which is no small matter, and move on, through the chaos in here and out there" really resonated for me. it was the after i found horrible, not the during. in the during, i was too caught up in the wonder of him to have to actually deal with myself.

we had just moved back to North America after years of vagabonding when we had - and lost - our son, who was our firstborn. but i found myself longing to be elsewhere during much of the first year of healing and grieving, not just to escape my own present but to have the opportunity to explore the meaning of loss outside the silence of my culture. Varanasi sounded more holy and more hopeful to me then that i had ever imagined it could.
September 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterBon
That was beautiful and so meaningful. I know you will carry him in your heart forever. Never be afraid to tell people about him. They need to know how important he is and always will be to you and your family. Let them know that even though his existance here with you was short, it was powerful. You will never forget him and why should anyone else?
September 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterVicki
Katie, this is so beautifully written, so vivid and moving. Every single word rang peals of truth and resonance in my heart.
Yes, indeed, little miracles we all are, all our children are... "chaos of matter, capable of birthing light even with our limitations." I know my son brought us light, I am just not sure I am capable of emitting any light, but I am going to keep trying...
Thank you for this beautiful piece of writing, so full of wisdom.
September 29, 2008 | Registered Commenterjanis
Very beautiful, very vivid. Thank you for sharing.
September 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterNatalie
Thank you, everyone, for you kind responses.

Kate, yes, I know what you mean. And I think your instinct to "offer it up" is a good one. I can learn from that too. Often in Buddhism we make offerings to deities to gain merit and we offer good and pleasing things. I think when people say things like you experienced, or like, "oh, well. you're young. you can have another," like I'd just burned a batch of cookies or something, they really are meaning to help. So, while their statements don't please me I can offer it up, let it go, not take in their unintentionally painful message and offer their intention of goodwill up to benefit all beings. It's like politely taking the nasty carrot-cake offered, and not eating it too. Thanks for phrasing it that way.

Janis-- Don't get me wrong. I had days that were dark, dark, dark too. I came close to turning out my own light, in fact. Do try, and when you can't and you're too tried to try, 'cause I think we've all had those days--do NOTHING, just HOLD ON. It's okay to do nothing, sometimes that's best.

Bon-- yeah, hummm ... "the after i found horrible", the after-death, it is a weird globulous existence of emotion that we don't know how to do with in this culture. Much like in this culture, opposed to others, we don't really know what to do with the after-birth. What an ironic twist you've hit on. In this culture, as opposed to others that have more practical uses for after-birth like nourishment or fertilizer, we ignore and shun the after-death too. I guess we're some of the weird ones who want to make use of it, and try to honor it, and use it wisely to grow--the after-death I mean. I didn't save the after-birth, that stuff is horribly icky. Just kidding. It's okay to make jokes in this group, right?
September 29, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterKatie
Katie, this is simply stunning.

As a historian, I too have wondered why there is no word, no nice tidy term, to define parents who have lost children. Am I to take from that that I am still a "parent"? Because I am the oddest, most jumbled kind of parent I know.

I love what you said about the time with Liam and knowing only love. I felt similar. There came a time when the news was just so bad, that I felt the only thing I instinctively knew how to do was hold her, love her, and call her my daughter. In some respects it was very freeing. Afterwards it was suffocating. I'm trying to be more "out" about my experience because I'm tired of hiding her, tired of playing into social conventions of what is comfortable, tired of treating her like she wasn't here and my grief wasn't real. But it's hard to have out -- I wish we did have a symbol. It would make it so much easier.
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered Commentertash
"Offer up..." I actually hadn't thought of it that way, but you're right Katie - I certainly don't hold it against people who say things like "Ben is your miracle baby" or "thank goodness Ben was a fighter". When that happens I stand outside myself a bit, imagine the universe standing with me and ask for witness. In my heart I'm saying "Oh no, no, it wasn't that way... did you hear that? No..." and will that presence to reply "Yes, that's right, it's not that way, and you know that, and I know that, and that's enough."

And even though I still get that physical response of the tightened throat - my body grimacing at something that feels like an injustice, that the world can't see Liam in the same light I saw him in - I feel peaceful. I feel like I *am* being witnessed. I'm thankful to people who say offhand comments like that because they help me to better occupy my love for Liam, to root deeper into the earth of what I know to be our truth, mine and his and Ben's.

Also, I've got a question I'd meant to ask you: as a buddhist, what rituals or mantras or sentiments or practical things can you call on to try and get through the difficult moments? How do you reclaim occupation of that spacious mind again? Do you meditate or chant or visit a meaningful place or speak to a mentor, or speak to him?
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterkate
Simply beautiful. Thank you for sharing this and for sharing Liam with us. He is, indeed, a miracle.

Someone once commented that the day my twins died must have been the "worst day of my life." Like you, I struggled to explain that it was, in fact, one of the most beautiful days of my life. Sorrowful, yes. But not terrible. How could I ever think of the one day I will hold my son and daughter in this lifetime as awful?

I like how you described the whole experience with Liam as one of love. I felt that too with my twins. I loved them, I loved our nurses, I loved our family that came to see them and hold them, and I loved every single person that sent us a card or left us a meal on our doorstep. There really was a whole lotta love going on in the midst of something that also felt quite tragic.
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterLori
I've often thought about the question about why there is no word for a parent who has lost a child. Perhaps because it was so common for so long that pretty much everyone fell into that categoy? It's only very recently that the assumption has been that every -- or almost every -- child who is born will survive childhood.

I once was doing some research based on census forms from the 19th century. For each woman there were two questions: Number of children born to this person and number of children living. In almost no case were the two answers the same.

Lovely post.
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterniobe
ladies, these folks might need you and your wisdom and kindness. http://elmcitydad.wordpress.com/
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterjen
A few weeks ago a new colleague asked me if I have any children.

My answer usually depends on who is asking, really. I tend to have a gut instinct regarding how I believe they'll react. I like this woman, and I felt comfortable choking out my answer.

She stopped, looked at me in shock, and threw her arms around me without a word, for a good long squeeze. It was, for me, a perfect response.

I was incredibly moved by this, Katie. Thank you for sharing.
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJen
jen - another reader has already emailed us about elmcitydad, and we're in the midst of at least reaching out to let them know we're here, if and when they're ready for company. Thank you, though, for making sure we were aware. We always appreciate that.
xo
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterkate
Yes, Kate, we are all miracles. Thank you for sharing the miracles of your love and your son. I have always looked at mourning and pain as the dues of joy, compassion, and peace. And so it goes...
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMartha
"Kids who lose parents have a name. Husbands and wives who lose their spouses have a name. What do you call parents who lose their babies? It’s an unnamed, and mostly unvoiced, situation of despair."
We included a similar passage in our Hope's funeral, just over a month ago. This piece is beautiful, and even made me smile, somewhat of a rarity these days in the six weeks since the full term loss of my first child. Thank you.
September 30, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterSally
I wish I could see anything but pain and hurt about the loss of my son. He was still born. nine months later and I still cant seem to feel anything but sorrow. Maybe the difference is that I didn't get to hear that first breath or the first cry. Katie if you could tell me how you got to any of that joy, I would love to know. I am sorry if this just sounds bitter, I am just really hurting and looking for answers.
courtney
October 1, 2008 | Unregistered Commentercourtney
I read this post last night and thought it was beautiful. I hadn't decided whether I would leave a comment, but the dream I had last night was surely because of this. In my dream, I am arriving at the cemetary for Noah's burial. The paths are all covered in poppies. I walked through them to my baby's final resting place. At first, it was sad, but when I woke up I felt a strange sense of peace. I don't know what the dream means, but maybe it is just Noah sending me his love. Thank you.
October 1, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJennifer
Courtney, it's kate, not katie... but I had to offer something up. I really do think it's a matter of time... and so many other factors that we don't know about your situation - your support network, the day-to-day demands of your life and family.

Just remember that in this space we're all at different points in our own stories. I'm 18 months out - for me, reaching the one-year anniversary of my son's death was a huge turning point. Katie - I'm sure she'll respond much more eloquently than I - has had a few years since her loss, as many women here have. Please don't look around you in a space like this and think "Everyone else seems to be okay, and I'm not...". Look around you and say, "Others seem to have found some peace, or some acceptance... and that's pretty good odds."

Be patient with yourself, okay? We all hold you just as you are, at the exact point of your journey. We understand.
xo
October 1, 2008 | Registered Commenterkate
Oh, and Jennifer.. that was a profound dream. Thank you so much for sharing it.
October 1, 2008 | Registered Commenterkate
Thank you, Kate, I needed that insight. I do compare myself to much. I was not taking into account that many of you have made it past the one year mark, which means you've made it through all the big holidays without your loved babies.

Unfortunately, my support is not what I would like it to be or what it should be. I have talked with a counslor and she is the one that directed me here.

I have one wonderful friend I can turn to, and Kate you said the very thing she keeps tell me--be patient with myself.

That would be the third time in the last 24 hours someone told me that. I will try.

Thanks again, Kate and Katie
October 1, 2008 | Unregistered Commentercourtney
Katie, you know, it's interesting (in that way that things can be interesting when we are discussing dead babies) that even though my son was stillborn, I also felt that overwhelming love and awe, much more than the sorrow, in the short time that we held his body. In fact, I remember my husband asking me how I was, and me telling him that I was OK just then, but I am making no promises for when we let his little body go.

Thank you for this beautiful and touching piece.
October 2, 2008 | Registered Commenterjulia
Courtney ---
I've just logged on to find your post after awhile away from the computer, and I'm responding right away. This won't be that comforting to hear, but for me I had to 'walk there' to 'get to' it. The sorrow and anger you feel IS the path to get there. At least it was for me. I spent a yr and a half spinning my wheels and trying to 'make the best of it' and 'searching for a bigger meaning for it all', which was good. And then I had to give in to the soul-melting, reality-cracking, banshee-like howling, suicidal-thoughts inducing pain of it all and let myself be devoured by the pain (with guidance from a very wise psychologist and medication to abate some symptoms. Reach for relief anyway you can-- no shame in that!). And that was after I had cried what I thought were all the tears a person could cry. You don't have to 'get to' joy. That is not your mission right now. You just have to feel what ever you're feeling as fully as you can, and then open up to it even further. Then just hold on and never, never, never, never, never, give up. Joy will come to you! I really think the more I searched for a way to make the pain stop the more I evaded happiness' return. I 'got to' joy by being really really really sad and reaching out anyway, if that makes any sense, just like you did here in this forum. Honestly, it was at least three yrs before I was not so sad that I couldn't even appreciate the sun shining. And still, almost 10 yrs. later joy isn't a place I feel like I got to, it's a place I have to be still and awake to and let it open from within that gap inside that the pain bore into me. But when joy does open up, it is so profound that I don't for a minute regret every wounded step I take to get to it.
October 8, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterkatie
Courtney --
Yikes! I realized after I posted that in my hast to respond my post might have sounded discouraging instead of encouraging. I'm not very blog savvy yet, and didn't know how to recall it to correct the tone. I was so worried when I read your post 'cause I think I recognized some desperation in it. I just wanted to be honest about the raw pain of this experience since so often we don't see that truth of it mirrored to us when we are in the trenches of our loss, and I think my instinct was to jump in there with you and grab your hand. My instinct was to be really honest about the uncomfortable journey I took as a way of answering your question about how I got through it. So, what I meant to say was it may not be comforting to hear it was a hard hard path, but please do be compassionate with yourself and know it is path. And I do want to try to offer some comfort by saying I hope you feel you have one more person--me (and I'm sure many others like Kate and the other Blue Poppy Parents on the site) to turn to.
October 9, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterkatie
Thank you for your honestly, Katie! I was desperate when I wrote the last post. I have come here with my hand out looking for someone to guide me. Do not worry your first post let me know that its ok to still be mourning nine months later. Yesterday was the nine month to the day. To me, having people acknowldge me and my grief and then validate it helps. I know today more then before that I need to hear what you said, stop trying to escape and just feel. When I stop trying to run away and hide from the pain, I can start healing. Thank you. Please don't worry no harm done.
October 9, 2008 | Unregistered Commentercourtney

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.